my brother has a question

[rikufan1995]

my brother has a question, he says when roxas was fighting sora in that cutsecne at twtnw, roxas says "why did he chose u". he thinks he's refurring to terra, but i think he's talking about xemnas. what do u ppl think

 

[Iridium]

I really don't think Roxas would have known Terra at all honestly.

 

[Gabo]

No.
Hes referring to DiZ/AtW

 

[Crimson Jazz]

Terra wasn't even thought of when Kingdom Hearts 2 was released...

And Roxas is referring to DiZ.

 

[cananthegreat]

Ur brother eh?


Yh it's DiZ

 

[rikufan1995]

Ur brother eh?


Yh it's DiZ

ya my brother im only posting this to prove him wrong i know that roxas knew nothing about terra

 

[Some Dude1]

it was a mistranlation it was sopost to say keyblade not he

 

[DarkSoldier85]

I'm pretty sure he meant Riku, but this has been argued about since the beginning of time.

 

[E.J.]

Hes talking about Ansem the Wise.

 

[Gabo]

it was a mistranlation it was sopost to say keyblade not he

uhm.
No.
It refers to AtW saying as AtW wanted Sora to vanquish the Order.

It being the Keyblade wouldn't make sense, for the simple fact Roxas also could use the keyblade.

I'm pretty sure he meant Riku, but this has been argued about since the beginning of time.

That'd make no sense.

 

[FINALDISNEY]

that is a mis-translation;its supposed to be "it" not "he"

hes referring to the keyblade

 

[gelandporn]

uhm.
No.
It refers to AtW saying as AtW wanted Sora to vanquish the Order.

It being the Keyblade wouldn't make sense, for the simple fact Roxas also could use the keyblade.

As FinalDisney said, the original Japanese said "it" and not "he." He's talking about the keyblade, not Ansem the Wise.

The answer to Roxas' question is Sora's friends (Roxas says "I see, that's why" when he looks at Sora surrounded by the images of friends on the floor panel). Or rather, that his friends give him his power, and therefore, he has a strong heart. Obviously, the strong heart would be why the Keyblade chose Sora.

AtW did not choose Sora. He used him. There was no choice in the matter, and, in any case, Sora's friends would not be the answer as to why AtW would have "chose" Sora.

Just because Roxas uses the keyblade doesn't mean that it makes no sense. Roxas was simply asking why the keyblade originally chose Sora. If I received something because my twin brother received it first, I would naturally want to know why my brother had received it.

 

[Smile]

It being the Keyblade wouldn't make sense, for the simple fact Roxas also could use the keyblade.

No, he just left the Organization to understand why he had the Keyblade - namely, why did Sora have it.
So he asked him, only they mistranslated it.
*points at GA's post*

 

[Nutari]

I really don't think Roxas would have known Terra at all honestly.

Why do u say that cuz i think that ven and roxas are one and the same

 

[Smile]

Why do u say that cuz i think that ven and roxas are one and the same

1) if Terra chose Sora, it was to put a part of Ven inside him or whatever.
2) Terra chose Riku.

 

[UltimaKSGeek]

i believe that roxas may have known 'about' terra but not everything cause he is connected to ventus in some way

 

[Konsoumis]

Who is the AtW anyways also it is a mistranslation Roxas meant to say it not he.

 

[Smile]

AtW = Ansem the Wise.

And I wouldn't just throw Ven-Roxas theories like that in a single sentence. It's insulting, in a way.

 

[Danica Syer]

So wait is he talking Sora or somebody else is what I wanna know. XD Or Ansem the Wise?

 

[XenonSovereign]

Terra wasn't even thought of when Kingdom Hearts 2 was released...

And Roxas is referring to DiZ.

Actually, BBS was in production when KH2 was made, but was halted because of Re:CoM...