Super Mario Sunshine or Galaxy?

[Twilight12]

So basically, I just found my SMS and i was playing it. I miss playing it now and i remembered how much fun I had with this game. the F.L.U.D.D idea IMO was great. I've heard alot of people putting it down while they praise Galaxy and vice-versa. I'm just a Mario fantatic, so just slap on the Mario tag and im up for it. Atleast, I have to try it right? lol anyways. Tell me which game ou prefered and why. What were your pros and cons about this game?

 

[Sean]

Galaxy. By far.

It's just my kind of game. You have more freedom and you aren't limited to an Island...

 

[Zephyr]

mario sunshine can be extremely painful and hard in some parts. mario galaxy has somewhat a moderate level. both games are fine i guess.

 

[Twilight12]

Galaxy. By far.

It's just my kind of game. You have more freedom and you aren't limited to an Island...

How so? Srsly, think of rosalinas ship or w.e as delfino plaza, its basically the same thing :\

 

[Zephyr]

mario sunshine does seem more fast paced than mario galaxy. that's a noticeable difference.

 

[Sean]

In terms of the levels. There's just so much more space (no pun intended). And bosses require just a bit more strategy to defeat. Though I must admit SMS was challenging in some places, like the hotel part. Oh dear God I hated that.

 

[Twilight12]

lmao. srsly, i just replayed that today and finding those recoins was a b*tch! lol. I suppose it did have more space, it was on the wii anyways. In terms of difficuly and gameplay though, which was better?

 

[darkheart709]

i prefer galaxy although i really don't get why people bash sunshine so much, yeah it didn't have that super mario 64 touch to it but it was still a good game. galaxy to me has more of that feel that SM64 had, with all the differetn worlds and such, everything just felt expanded while SMS had that somewhat smaller feeling to it. i think it was because because of the tropical setting

in terms of difficulty i'd say galaxy is easier unless you are going for all 121 stars, which some can be so ****ing annoying, like the manta races and the rolling ball one

in gameplay i say galaxy was more fun, it had good motion controls and good platforming

 

[Lycanthrope]

Galaxy is out of the world compared to Sunshine. [shitty attempt at pun]

Also, Sunshine wasn't that great. So much more to do in Galaxy.

 

[Iridium]

Galaxy overall.

Graphics
Gameplay
Replayability
Fun

Epic! Sunshine was a great idea at the time but it's predossesser Galaxy is everything sunshine isn't, even without analog camera control (which blowed in sunshine anyway)

 

[Sean]

Galaxy is out of the world compared to Sunshine. [shitty attempt at pun]

Oh you can do better than that.

Plus, I like Galaxy's lighting...

 

[(?Cmurder?)]

Mario 64 is better than both, easily.

 

[Sean]

Uh...no it's not.

 

[Vox]

lol that was funny. Mario 64 is classic therefor it owns. but me i prefer Sunshine. sorry galaxy people Sunshine just does it for me Galaxy is just to much.

 

[Sora3525]

Super mario Galaxy because it rocks.

 

[bkmon]

Galaxy because i liked the different levels and I loved the graphics.

 

[Azrael]

Super Mario Galaxy for sure, Sunshine was okay...

 

[Shadow Soldier]

The only reason why people hated Sunshine compared to the other marios, was the Pre-Rendered mario in the opening cutscene.

Bottom line, Mario Galaxy is the true successor to Mario 64. Sunshine was just to tie people over.

 

[D]

I hated that little squirter that you had in Sunshine. So annoying. I would definatley prefer Galaxy.

 

[Crimson Jazz]

Both games are EXTREMELY fun.

Even though I am a bit nostalgic, I prefer Galaxy.