Organization so bad?

[Xao]

I realize this probably isnt the first time this question had been brought up, but I was wondering.. was the Organization so bad for just wanting a heart and becoming complete beings. Would something so bad happen if they had hearts? They never stated any actions of controlling all worlds to do their bidding, granted they did cause alot of mischief, but some may think there actions were justified. Just a thought

 

[Felix]

Not really i kinda feel sorry that they don't have emotions

 

[Spic Steve]

Demyx deserves one, so does Axel, Zexion, Roxas, and Vexen

 

[scubasteve]

Demyx deserves one, so does Axel, Zexion, Roxas, and Vexen

I agree with Roxas and Axel....not Zexion and Demyx....

I'm not even going to mention why Vexen doesn't deserve a heart. Vexen doesn't deserve a heart...he deserves to get smacked upside the head by the next person who looks at him.

 

[var1ables]

They're cool actually. Think about it, they wanted to be whole things, they weren't to bad, i liked them. It seemed to me that they wanted something that sora was all for, the only one that was a little crazy was.. xenmas... and that was just because he was all for the crazy darkness.

 

[Bumja]

the org just wanted hearts and they would do watever it took, good or bad things that they did, to get them, and i feel sry for them because STUPID SORA had to DESTROY MOST OF THEM!!!!! lol but they lived in darkness, not the light, so that does kinda make them evil, but anyway maybe they should have hearts

 

[Felix]

No because riku lived in darkness but he is good.

 

[Spic Steve]

Darkness isn't evil, look at mickey.
Darkness= some light
Evil=No light

 

[Bumja]

riku wasnt in the organization, he just wore the black robe, and he wasnt a nobody, so that cant be

 

[Veritas]

Darkness isn't evil, look at mickey.
Darkness= some light
Evil=No light

Incorrect.
Darkness=No light. Darkness is the absence of light.
Evil= the misuse of power.

You can weild light and still be evil. If Sora decided to go crazy and kill everyone in the game, would he be good or evil? If you said evil, there's a problem if you believe that light means good. He weilds light, but he is evil. The same goes for Mickey. If he uses darkness for good, he is not evil it's only when he misuses the darkness.

 

[Spic Steve]

Mickey said, no matter how much dark, there is some lightin CoM, not evil

 

[Bumja]

i think soras dad is right about this, im not taking sides or anything, but i think his opinion is better

 

[Veritas]

Mickey said, no matter how much dark, there is some lightin CoM, not evil

He was talking about the heart. The heart is made up of both light and dark. It's stated throughout KH1 as well. The closer you get to the light. The bigger your shadow becomes. Darkness is the absence of light. Darkness is the absence of light. You can have them mix, but darkness will be no light. Light will be no darkness. The power Mickey uses is darkness. He uses no light, or he'd be weilding twilight.

 

[Spic Steve]

what im saying,(sorry for wording wrong) is mickeys dark, but good, so hes not Evil, or hed be bad

 

[Veritas]

what im saying,(sorry for wording wrong) is mickeys dark, but good, so hes not Evil, or hed be bad

That's what I was saying lol. I was saying that darkness is not evil. It's just when you use darkness in the wrong way. Think Spiderman. "With great power comes great responsibility."

EDIT: The only light Mickey has is in his heart. He chose to use darkness for good though. What I was saying is he's good but weilds darkness. He does not use light. Do not associate light with good and dark with bad. In this game, it has basically stated both can be bad or good. It just depends on the user.

 

[Spic Steve]

and then he falls on his face lol we were both right, we just said it different

 

[NobodyImportant]

It's not light or darkness that makes you good or evil, it's your own interpretation and resultant use of it that determines it. Axel didn't do anything bad except cause mayhem and defeat whatsisface. Demyx was just following orders. (and sucked at doing so in the process!)
Zexion, well...I think he was just testing Sora.

Riku was in darkness, yet he used it for good. Same with Mickey. I'd say it would be possible for someone in the light to use it for evil too, just don't have an example unless you count Xehanort before he split into Xemnas and his heartless.

 

[SH_Brat]

They might not have been bad, but they were going about getting hearts the wrong way! If they really wanted hearts they should of tried to seek out their heartless. That way they could release their hearts and turn back to normal! No matter how you look at it it's wrong... What's worse is they knew what they were doing.

 

[Spic Steve]

That means we figured out the answer to nomuras "riddle", Can the keyblade be used for evil

 

[Lilly]

I think the Org. are that bad..Ok Xenmas was not other! Though I felt sorry for them! SORA kill of them all..Geez I hate him for this cause I really like the org. very much though!

And I agree that they should have a heart it odesn't wrong to find or get a heart but they just do it in wrong way. It was they who begin with all choas of course.