Xiao said:
Just because he forgot her for a while doesn't mean nothing ever happened..
Actually... it does. Have you finished Chain of Memories and Reverse/Rebirth? The point was to make Sora Marluxia's slave, thus giving Marluxia power over the Keyblade. Do you
honestly think anyone could have stood up to the power of Sora and the Organization? Or that Marluxia would ever relinquish his control over Sora?
The answer to both is a simple no. And because of that, Sora and Kairi would have never been together to have BHK and Naminé.
that's very true but she could always be lying for reasons yet to discover
It's become obvious that you're not going to change your mind. If you have to toss comments like that at me to defend the theory then there's something very, very wrong with it.
first of all, when did namine ever introduce herself to the BHK? in the trailers, sure you see them talking, but that doesn't mean she's introducing herself.
In the JF 2005 and E3 2005 (public) trailers. If you check GameSpot's trailer impressions, they clearly state that Naminé was introducing herself to BHK -- saying that she was a witch, among other things.
second of all, if she is introducing herself, it could be that she had to erase BHK's memories for the same reasons that she might have lied to sora.
Simply restating what I've already said: "If you have to toss comments like that at me to defend the theory then there's something very, very wrong with it."
It does if you really think about it XD
If you
really have to think about it, you're trying too hard and overanalyzing the situation to an extreme. If things can't be laid out in front of you with concrete evidence and a
tiny bit of imagination, it's more than likely wrong.