- Joined
- Mar 20, 2015
- Messages
- 272
- Awards
- 3
It's the "moto" part that has me questioning the meaning of this scene. Translating it as "has-beens" is kinda clever but it makes it sound like Marluxia is responding to Sora's taunt, whereas in Japanese it sounds to me more like he genuinely doesn't understand what Sora means by "moto." "Zuibun" indicates a level of surprise or consternation, so it sounds like he doesn't "get" that Sora is referring to a past version of a new construct, which makes sense if we read Sora's "Shin (新) Juusan Kikan" as "New Organization Thirteen" and that makes Marluxia's correction to "Shin (秦)" as in "true" more close to the English reading of that term as "singular/only" rather than "accurate/exact." In other words it sounds like Marluxia is saying, "The 'true' Organization, i.e. the only one that has ever existed." It just seems strange to me to highlight this back and forth if they're both talking about the same thing, but maybe it's just a long-winded way for Marluxia to get around to reintroducing himself to Sora and I'm overthinking it lol.
As for the theory, I haven't been following Ux so I dunno much about how Lauriam is involved in the plot of it, but I get the feeling this Marluxia is actually Marluxia and not Lauriam (just a gut feeling, could definitely be wrong). Good thinking drawing on his connection to Ven, though. That does give him relevance beyond either the new or the old Organization and might inform more about his past behavior and what we can expect from him in KH3, so it's definitely worth keeping in mind. If he did actually find the Chamber of Waking, or even figured out what/who was inside of it, that might explain his decision to take over the Organization (and gives added context to positioning himself as the leader of the CO team): if Ven is, say, the key to the rest of the Dandelions, that might be related to Marluxia's ultimate goal, and he might have needed to prevent Xehanort from getting to him. Which might give him reason to assist Sora in KH3, if waking Ven up advances his interests and frustrates MX.
I honestly just saw it as Marluxia being amused rather than surprised. Zuibun also means extremely as well. Also "moto" could mean former. He could also be surprised/amused that Sora still thinks of him from the former Organization since he says in the original dialogue in response to Sora's " Come out former Organization XIII" is "Former? That's a way to put it." Then Sora goes on about how that the Former(Moto) Org. XIII used Nobodies unless he's in the New(Shin) Org. XIII. Then Marluxia goes on to introduce himself as "I'm Marluxia of True(Shin) Org. XIII." If he truly didn't understand what Sora was saying he would have continued to inquire about the "Former/Moto" remark from Sora. I figured he understands what Sora says and used a play on words with him(pun since they're basically saying Shin Juusan Kinkan" but Marluxia sees it as the true Organization because that's what it really is. Young Xehanort said as much. The former Organization wasn't the real deal and Marluxia recognizes this now. But either way I guess we'll have to wait for the game to find out the whole deal. Plus by the slim chance Marluxia wasn't with the group, I don't think Xemnas would allow Marluxia to use his Nobody henchmen for his own schemes that could interfere with Xehanort as Xemnas controls all Nobodies.