Re: Shiro Amano's Kingdom Hearts 1.5 Recap now in English!
The trouble for me is the CoM manga. CoM is just driven by the Org members, so when you make them a joke, you make the whole product a joke. And that would be fine if the joke was funny, but it's not for me (Days and post-Days KH2 are funny, though). Actually, I was liking the CoM manga more than the KH1 manga, with its intermixing Sora and Riku's stories and the Agrabah segment, but then the plot kicked in.
And while I agree that the central characters have better personalities in KH2 and Days... not in CoM. In fact I'd argue Sora's characterization was outright undermined. It's a bad second impression I've had a lot of trouble shaking. Even the spectacular Days manga hasn't shaken that bad impression, probably because it detonates one of my favourite scenes with another gag Org member.
(That one scene notwithstanding, seriously: everyone read the Days manga.)